Corpus iurisprudentiae Romanae

Repertorium zu den Quellen des römischen Rechts

Digesta Iustiniani Augusti

Recognovit Mommsen (1870) et retractavit Krüger (1928)
Convertit in Anglica lingua Scott (1932)
Dig. VII3,
Quando dies usus fructus legati cedat
Liber septimus
III.

Quando dies usus fructus legati cedat

(When the Legacy of an Usufruct Vests.)

1Ulpianus libro septimo decimo ad Sabinum. Quamquam usus fructus ex fruendo consistat, id est facto aliquo eius qui fruitur et utitur, tamen semel cedit dies: aliter atque si cui in menses vel in dies vel in annos singulos quid legetur: tunc enim per dies singulos vel menses vel annos dies legati cedit. unde quaeri potest, si usus fructus cui per dies singulos legetur vel in annos singulos, an semel cedat: et puto non cedere simul, sed per tempora adiecta, ut plura legata sint: et ita libro quarto digestorum Marcellus probat in eo, cui alternis diebus usus fructus legatus est. 1Et ideo si is fructus legatus sit, qui cottidie percipi non potest, non erit inutile legatum, sed dies habebunt legatum, quibus frui potest. 2Dies autem usus fructus, item usus non prius cedet quam hereditas adeatur: tunc enim constituitur usus fructus, cum quis iam frui potest. hac ratione et si servo hereditario usus fructus legetur, Iulianus scribit, quamvis cetera legata hereditati adquirantur, in usu fructu tamen personam domini exspectari, qui uti et frui possit. 3Item si ex die usus fructus legetur, dies eius nondum cedet, nisi cum dies venit: posse enim usum fructum ex die legari et in diem constat. 4Non solum autem usus fructus ante aditam hereditatem dies non cedit, sed nec actio de usu fructu: idemque et si ex die fuerit legatus usus fructus: denique Scaevola ait agentem ante diem usus fructus nihil facere, quamvis alias qui ante diem agit, male agit.

1Ulpianus, On Sabinus, Book XVII. Although an usufruct consists of enjoyment, that is to say, in some effort exerted by him who enjoys and uses the right; still, it vests but once, and it is different from where something is bequeathed every month, or every day, or every year; for then the legacy vests daily, monthly, or yearly. Wherefore the question may arise, where an usufruct is bequeathed to anyone, for every day, or for every year, does it vest but once? I think that it does not, but as many times as it is mentioned, so that there are several legacies. Marcellus approves this opinion in the Fourth Book of the Digest, where an usufruct is bequeathed to anyone for alternate days. 1Therefore, if an usufruct is bequeathed which cannot be enjoyed every day, the bequest will not be invalid, but it will vest on the day when it can be enjoyed. 2An usufruct, however, and likewise an use, will not vest before the estate is entered upon, for an usufruct is not created until someone can immediately enjoy it. According to this rule, if the usufruct is bequeathed to a slave forming part of an estate, Julianus holds that, although other legacies may be acquired by the estate, in the case of an usufruct we must wait for the person of the owner who can use and enjoy the same. 3Moreover, if an usufruct is bequeathed from a certain day, it will not vest until the day arrives; for it is established that an usufruct can be bequeathed from a certain time or until a certain time. 4Not only does an usufruct not vest before the estate is entered upon, but a right of action based upon usufruct does not do so either; and the same rule applies where an usufruct is bequeathed after a certain day; hence, Scævola says that a party who brings an action before the day of the usufruct will gain nothing; although any legal procedure which is instituted before the proper time is void.